Showing posts with label susan pevensie - fanfiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label susan pevensie - fanfiction. Show all posts
Saturday, January 15, 2022
Nobby's Daring
The two outside - George and Georgina - received Nobby and Charlie who had been posing as trying to "shoot a rope into the castle" Errol Flynn version of Robin Hood. Nobby was glad to see them, but the others told him they needed to get caught to do a diversion for the ones getting in. George and Georgina stand back.
When Nobby and Charlie are caught - it doesn't take too long, the two groups of five meet before the front porch.
The ten men stand menacing around Nobby and Charlie.
"What do you think you are doing?"
Charlie and Nobby didn't answer.
"We have some more men inside if someone else is trying to be funny."
A rustle which was very weak gave Charlie and Nobby some hope, they were "trying to be funny" ... but Nobby kicked a stone on the ground to hide that rustle, and the men did not notice. They were very well built.
Keeping their attention could prove to be painful. Even so ... Nobby kicked a stone again.
"Hey, stop that - we pay the people who rake the gravel path, don't destroy their work!"
He knew this would hurt, but he disobeyed.
"OK, you are asking for it ..."
The man punched a hard fist with a long windup into his stomach.
He heard Georgina shout "brutes!" and thought "no ..."
Soon Georgina Kirrin and George White were caught too.
Nobby was waiting still held in the arms of two men.
"So, you kind of betrayed your friend?"
Nobby didn't answer. He got a punch into his face with the notice:
"We don't like traitors ... we may use them, we don't like them."
He glimpsed over to Georgina who smiled very furtively, but triumphantly. Police were coming.
Thursday, January 13, 2022
The Archers Do Their Work.
Over the fence, then onto the house, there were twenty feet or so to the path of the arrow. Charlie carefully laid down the strong but slender rope in large swathes over the ground, tied it to an arrow, shot at a wooden panelling part of the roof where it met the house.
The arrow stuck into it with a big thud. He started to draw the rope towards himself, though careful not to pull too strongly, just so as to slowly make it appear he was trying to climb the fence with the rope - when he arrived below the fence, a window opened, and a man, somewhat angry, took the arrow, pulled it out of the wood, and shouted to him:
"Ha, this only works in movies."
Charlie turned around and tried to escape.
The angry man turns inside the window and tells his fellows:
"See him running? No? See the rope? The arrow came from there ... see if he's still around"
About five men get out from the window, climbing down on the security ladder, and they use the rope, doubled, to climb up over the fence one after another and down on the other side. They then follow the rope to catch Charlie ...
Meanwhile, Nobby also shoots, at the other side of the house, where the front porch is, thirty feet, and about the same thing happens. He's detected, five men are told to get out, they do so through the front porch and chase Nobby.
Thursday, January 24, 2019
Prologue to Chronicle on Susan Pevensie : Chiefly on Fan Fiction
I'm not sure if you know what fan fiction is.
It does not mean I write a novel entirely of my own, with all characters entirely of my own and take credit for that.
It doesn't mean I take someone else's novel and someone else's characters and change names and other items of exact wording and take credit for that (that's called plagairism).
It means I take the characters from someone else's novel and put them in a new novel or short story. I give them credit for original novels and take credit for my own imagination on what the original author(s) left undescribed.
As I said them, plural, not him, singular, this is actually fan fic on more authors' work than just C. S. Lewis' Seven Chronicles of Narnia.
As I wanted a girl somewhat more tomboyish than Susan Pevensie, and Lucy was already dead, and even Jill Pole was so, in came George (dare I mention at the end you may even call her Georgina?) from Enid Blyton. As I had Susan Pevensie persecuted by a Rabadash like person at the very first chapter, I felt like giving her a decent husband at the end. And Lost Road by Tolkien, John Ronald, came to mind. And obviously I mixed up Audoin and Alboin while doing so. Meanwhile, as she is a person living in England after seeing Narnia, he's one who has seen Numenor. And the Lombards. And a few more. Both have memories of a world they cannot go to. I'm going to explain (or here am explaining) the mixup with Tolkien giving the two Errols some anonymity by exchanging the names of father and of son in them.
As the presumed authorial voice in nearly all of the seven chronicles (all but the last) is a Digory Kirke, who was child and (I presume) well into his youth when Sherlock Holmes was doing detective work on Baker Street, in comes Doctor Watson. With Holmes and Watson around, I can't keep Father Brown out ....
Some guys have a deep antipathy for the whole concept of fan fic, not to mention fan fic crossing over between different authors' different universes. While bad stuff exist, good stuff also exists and on Narnia, mine is not the most noble, but perhaps the most exhaustive. Susan fics (that is fan fictions about Susan Pevensie, notably after the Last Battle) are hard to find but seem to have been very prolific once, and they are difficult to do well. I think my attempt may be the best one of those still available, because I do try to tie together so many loose ends, but there are other fields of Narnian fan fic and some have done better than I there. In Narnia, not in England, as I am doing. The best type, of those I have seen, are set between most chapters of The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe and The Horse and His Boy. Or some even introduce Swanwhite.
If you are longing for something set in Narnia, don't waste your time on this one right now, Aslan had told Susan she would never return to Narnia. A Susan fic is per definition, nearly, set outside Narnia.
My Susan fic was provoked by Neil Gaiman's (more or less acknowledged) such. Even before I read it, because I had heard of it and of its faults. Not as if I took up the pen (or keyboard) same second, I'm not Reepicheep, but inspiration came not very much later.
Hans Georg Lundahl
Nanterre UL
St. Timothy of Ephesus
24.I.2019
PS, plagairism is of course meant to be plagiarism./HGL
Now, if you are not already there, go to chapter 1:
Susan has a bad fright.
http://enfrancaissurantimodernism.blogspot.com/2011/12/susan-has-bad-fright.html
Wednesday, December 12, 2018
Taking up residence.
In January 1950, she was going to start her work as gym teacher in Cherwell school - no, not the one established in 1963, this one was another thing, even if the name is similar. However, it was also in the Headington area.
It was a way from the Kilns, so she was more looking for a place closer to it than staying in the Kilns.
Also, praying for the dead as a Catholic, while Jack and Warnie were not unfriendly, they were also not into it (especially Warnie).
She had money left and borrowed some (interest free) from Jack, so she could buy a semidetached. Indeed, since part of the money was from Mr. White, she made an extra effort to forgive ... Simon's son.
She did not know his name even. Not his "Christian name" if you can say that of someone who wasn't christened ... still "God bless him, give him light to repent and not too heavy a penance."
Well, one day she held the key, walked from the car and to the house on Walton Street, and and stepped in. She put down a mat and a sleeping bag, and then fork, knife, table spoon, tea spoon, tea cup, deep plate, flat plate, frying pan, kettle, tea pot, and then napkin and towel and tooth brush, tooth paste, soap, shampoo.
AND she hung up a crucifix on the wall.
Now she was going to be fine until the other stuff arrived.
And within a week, it had arrived. Most of it was practical, and it was not much except for books (what is more practical than books?) and training equipment, bow and arrows, rubber band for musculation, and some stuff which had belonged to Lucy.
She opened the box and found a red whig which she had used on a theatrical once, and under it a few notebooks, both by Lucy and by ... old Digory Kirke.
She did not start reading, she started crying as she saw the whig, and promptly prayed a "requiescat in pace" for Lucy "if she needs it" - a qualification derived from her respect for Lucy's possible sainthood. Next morning, she was teaching push ups and getting up in two rings in ropes and things like that, and after a fairly long pass, she went to take tea with the other staff and in the corridor crossed ... Rose.
The cousin of Jill, whom she had met on the burial. They said hello and next lesson Rose was in her class.
The year was going to be interesting.
Rose meets Bobby
In the night she woke up, yes, it seems her boy was not quite as sleepy as she was.
"I'm tired, you know"
"OK - I'll try to keep awake a bit"
And she went on talking to the boy inside her.
"Yes, it's dark ..."
And, no, she didn't physically hear him answer, but she could imagine.
Anyway, ten minutes or twenty minutes or an hour or so later, she slept again.
In the morning, she tried to find the chamber pot - and couldn't. She walked across some planks set across the beams for some while, with a lit candle where there was no day light coming in.
In some places, there were just beams and some plaster between them, she was careful to go from one beam to another and set no foot on the plaster.
She then found - to the right - a door. As you may know, this was the studio of uncle Andrew. She turned the latch and went in to a room with a window, and with an armchair.
As she looked at the armchair, she heard someone yawn and ask "it's you isn't it?"
"How do you mean 'me'?"
"The girl who's pregnant, police are looking for you so you can abort, everyone's concerned because your house doctor got on radio and said you had a condition which made it ten times as dangerous for you than for any other girl of fourteen to have a child, and you have been kidnapped by evil cultists who want to force you to ..."
"The evil cultists - as you say - who want to force me to abort didn't manage to get me to the appointment ... thanks to Miss Pevensie, the teacher of my gym class."
"Oh, but didn't you know," the snarky voice went on, as someone rose from the armchair, "Miss Pevensie is an evil cultist!"
A boy not much older than herself, like 14 and fairly good looking - she added half and half "for a Gipsy" because he was a bit darker than a Traveller usually is - laughed.
"So am I."
She waited, somewhat bemused.
"I don't want you to abort either!"
"Thank you."
"Not even if you die. Women should die rather than abort."
"I don't think I would die, but I don't think I agree either ..."
"Well, too bad ... by the way, sorry I forgot your chamber pot, just came over this morning and slept in the chair"
Speaking of chamber pot ...
"Oh, here it is, you go out ... no, I go out, and you do what you need"
And he was out - and did she need that!
Someone should write a poem about getting to a toilet when you need one ... and yes, there was toilet paper.
"You are watching!" she cried out!
"Shsh! They can hear you!"
When she had downed the skirts, he came back in.
"Sure you mean women should die rather than abort?"
"Ma did. That's why I am alive. My cousin and her husband raised me for her, while my dad was in prison. And continued after he came out."
"What's your name? I'm Rose ... and what's your mother's name?"
"I'm Bobby. And ma who died was Lobby - as in Lobelia."
Tuesday, March 20, 2018
Nerva the Narnian in Telmar
Nerva abdicated. He had wanted to do this since the day when he got worried about the isopsephy of Μ. Νερουα and finally did so when the prophet on Patmos had been freed and he had arranged for Jews not to be persecuted.
Where should he go? To Narnia, where he was born? No, he was going to Patmos.
He arrived in a ship, but a storm took the hull. He had to swim to land. When he looked around, he was not on a Greek island, but ashore a lake in a wood, and there was no shipwreck behind him.
He walked ashore, sat down in the beautiful sunshine, and dried his clothes.
A beast, if you will call it that, came walking. A majestic lion.
"Esne leo quem vidit Ioannes?"
"Sum homo, sum leo, sum bos et sum aquila quem vidit."
"Et ille?"
"Non es propheta, non tibi narro historiam alterius."
"Scripsit autem de bestia quaedam cuius numerum isopsephicôs habeo in nomen Graecum."
Marcus Nerva paused.
"Erone bestia?"
"Non ita, hic latine et anglice loquuntur, tibique dabitur uxor quae ambis linguis loquitur. Graece hic non loquitur, non ob id Μαρκε Νερουα tibi timendum est."
"Et ubi eram?"
"Eris ο Μαρκος Νερβας. Et hic latine dicent Nervam, non Nerwam nomen tuum."
"Gratias!"
"Hoc debeo honori et meo prophetae : non enim sum Apollo, quem hic appellant Tash, non sum deus prophetiarum de quibus nullus exitus metuentibus."
Et Aslan iam non aderat, Marcusque autem Nerva audivit linguas quas non ante audivit. Tres viri aderant, unusque ex his, videns eum Romanum esse dixit "salve".
"Salve et tu," (paene dixisset salwe, sed meminit), "sum Nerva, Narnianus sum, quis es?"
"Pulverulentus Siccus vocor, pirata eram, nunc vivo in pace."
Eiusque filia futura erat uxor Nervae, et ab ea didicit anglice loquere.
And their descendants include one Caspian I, called Caspian the conqueror, and their descendants include King Tirian ...
Friday, August 25, 2017
Meanwhile, What about Rose?
While Susan was in the ferry to Ireland, Rose woke up late in a curious place and whondered for a moment where she was. Ah, yes, the attic of the empty house ... and in a pirate's den with lots of ginger beer bottles, some candles (there was a box of matches for her use), and something to cover the plaster between the beams : planks, a mat and some more. On an improvised "table" she saw a mark in the dust, where there had been a book.
She had been dusting the corner, but somehow that mark was glued, perhaps in solidified ginger beer. If you have read The Magician's Nephew by C. S. Lewis, you will know it was Polly Plumber who had prepared it. And, as you recall from the beginning of my book, or from the end of C. S. Lewis' The Last Battle, she had died in the railway accident. So had Digory Kirke, whom she had invited there when they were both children and had just become neighbours. But Rose had no idea of this. She was however aware - though there was no kicking yet - of the little life of a very tiny man inside her.
"Dear Eustace this is a curious place we are in, but we could be worse off, you know!"
She was fairly sure, even very sure, it was a boy, and she was thinking of her cousin Jill's friend (they had both died in the railway accident), as you can see.
And she felt hungry. And she saw, just outside where she was, there was some food left by the gipsies. Milk in a bottle, a bar of chocolate, bread, sardines. And there was a chamber pot, though she had no idea as yet where to empty it.
"Well, we've survived this round!"
She felt it was not just her baby, but herself too, who had escaped.
What she did then ... if you have been or known a pregnant woman, you may know. Afterwards she wondered when and where to empty the chamber pot, had no appetite and she drew the curtain to escape some of the smell.
"Afraid? We'll survive this too!" she said, as if thinking the reaction came from fear within her baby. As she calmed down (her stomach feeling better too) she presumed she had succeeded in soothing little Eustace. Perhaps she had.
And exhausted by growth of her offspring and by vomiting, she fell asleep. When she woke again, the chamber pot was no longer smelling. She looked out, there was a new and dry one, happily.
In she went, after a somewhat more humdrum use, took some chocolate, drank just a very little milk to it, wondered if she should light a candle, didn't and went to sleep after telling her boy inside:
"You liked that too, didn't you?"
But it was no real question, she was not in doubt.
Thursday, July 9, 2015
Macready and Tea
Susan had slept a few hours of well needed sleep. The sun was shining in through the window and warming the room more than the day outside. But what had woken her up was really the smell of a late breakfast or an early lunch. In the States they called that “brunch”. Fried potato and mushrooms harmonised with fried egg and a clear smell of tea getting poured into cups.
”Good morning, dear!”
”Good morning, but I think it must be close to noon …?”
”And yet it is morning to you. It is actually one o’ clock.”
”Oh, I’ve slept for hours. I must be on the run soon.”
”Indeed, but first you need to take a good meal, then to keep calm. If you run like you are hunted they will all see it is you.”
”They might see so anyway ?”
”Yes, but running isn’t getting any escapee very far, since the news run faster. Oh, yes, I’ve read it. If you don’t run, you may still be caught, and if they recognize you and try to , you must run for it and pray God gives you a good refuge. But if you run when nobody is chasing – unless you can pass it off as jogging – you are giving the impression of a person feeling hunted, a very fishy impression. ”
That made sense.
Macready stood up beside the table while Susan sat down, she took both plates out to the kitchen and returned with them filled with as much fried egg, potatoes and mushrooms as you like, plus some salt and pepper, and bread, while Susan was already sipping away at her tea, as invited to.
The jogging plan was dropped, since a jogging outfit would be cold at night and not very natural in most circumstances. ”And that’s no wonder, look at that baggy stuff!” – If this had been twenty years later and less cold in the season it would have been another story, but back in 1950 jogging was done by extreme health freaks (including in fact Susan who liked keeping fit for swimming, riding and archery).
No, normal outfit, but not that of the nurse, would have to do. You have of course realized that if Susan was caught, they would know someone had helped her. Susan pointed it out, Macready said ”Well, that can’t be helped. ”
Before finishing the meal and trying the outfit, Susan asked why Macready didn’t believe she was putting Rose in mortal danger, since that was the story of the papers and the radio.
”Oh that? Mother gave birth to me when she was twelve, going on thirteen, even without a caesarian. We had a hard life at first, but she did not regret it.” (Susan could imagine Macready had had a hard life.)
So, Susan took an outfit of Macready’s, a really dowdy one, unlike the fancy clothes she used to wear and which showed on photos. She even avoided to take lipstick.
”Now, you go to Oxford. Maybe the Inklings might help you. They were friends of old Professor … Kirke …”
And Macready sobbed. She had even missed being there to identify her old employer and nearly lost a chance to be at the funeral as well (though she was by no means late). She dried her eyes. No time for crying if one’s a Macready. She was glad Susan knew Clive Staples Lewis and Paxford.
”Here is for the train ticket to Oxford, and here is some food; you won’t have to buy too soon. Now, finish the meal and I’ll put your hair up in a bun so you’ll be less like the photos. ”
Susan finished the meal, got the hair up in a bun with Macready’s help, showed she could make it a bun again, then got helped again to make it a really good one. Macready told Susan as she left that she would herself be phoning Paxford, whom she knew personally.
Thursday, July 2, 2015
Macready
"MISS PE-VEN-SIE"
Susan looked up from the tea she was sipping. Oh yes, it was Mrs Macready all right. That voice was so itself after all these years.
She stammered: "You are mistaken, you must be thinking of someone else ...?"
"Oh nonsense!
"When you were eleven you hid in a wardrobe from me. Don't you think I didn't see you!
"I have been keeping an eye on you for some time now, an eye or two open.
"The news are out that you are escaped, and as tired as you look, there are slim chances you'll be taken for a nurse!"
"But what about night nurses?" Susan knew it was no ood to pretend, but she wanted some reassurance she wasn't as stupid as Mrs. Macready made it out.
"You were awake at daytime yesterday and all night through. A night nurse sleeps the days before doing night service and in the morning she's no more exhausted than you are a normal evening. Now, don't fuss, come with me. You need some hours' sleep, and thanks to us not being all that close, I am not suspect of helping you."
They went out after no significant delay. Susan had already paid the tea.
As they walked to the bus, Mrs Macready said: "Now, I heard what you did, and I have never heard of archery come to better use in our times.
"I knew you were a spunky girl, when faced with any battle you should fight in. As was the case here."
"How do you know that? Haven't all the news painted me out as a dangerous madwoman?"
"Oh, the news!" Mrs Macready said. "Look here, I don't know what happened in that wardrobe, but I do know you are not mad!
"When you defend the life of the unborn, you are not mad. Someone else is, or it wouldn't need defending. But not you!"
She paused and very quickly put finger on mouth before boarding the bus. Of course they went upstairs (for those who do not know, busses in London have two floors). And very fortunately, the upper floor wasn't empty, it was not yet rushing hours. It could easily have become so if Susan, tired as she was, had been left to herself and had dozed off for some hours.
Half an hour later, they were in another part of London, and they entered Mrs. Macready's rented flat.
"I'm afraid the sofa will have to do."
"Oh, it will be great!"
Despite the one cup of tea, she soon slept as soundly as with Mr and Mrs Beaver (and Lu, Pete, Ed) in that hiding place where they met Father Christmas in the morning. And yes, she thought of it just before going to sleep.
Sunday, October 5, 2014
How Susan met Rose E. Pole
Meanwhile, Aunt Alberta had seen the corpse of Jill, and gone to it, since she had been a close friend to Eustace those last years, especially that last year. She was not alone, there was a man with a girl, probably his daughter, since she reminded of him. They also reminded her of Jill Pole.
"Relatives of Jill, I presume? You must be the uncle and cousin, Paul Edward and Rose Ellen, I presume? My condoleances!"
"And you are," said Paul Edward, "the mother of Eustace, Alberta?"
"Indeed."
"Condoleances."
And Alberta insisted on inviting them to a treat, then and there, nearest tea room, an ice cream and soda for Rose and tea with cake for herself and Paul. They simply had "to take a pause from the grieving" as she put it. Strictly vegetarian and the tea room chosen as very certainly not a pub were they served any strong drink. You know her principles, and keeping low calory intake was not one of her strictest. As she was asked where Harold was, she explained there was some chance she was staying in Sevenoaks for the night, so he had been sent to arrange with the hotel - including for Susan.
Paul Edward was the divorced father of one daughter, he had also been lodging Jill and giving her an English as opposed to exotic education, while her parents were digging for bones somewhere all over the world, whereever there was a good dig to be made. Later they were among the veteran staff of Mary Leakey when she was a widow. This arrangement, while Experiment House was still open, lasted during holidays - hols as they said back then - but after it closed during terms too.
Jill had taken archery lessons for Susan, as said, but Rose - even now only thirteen - had been deemed too young to do so. Rose Ellen was silent, thought of her dead cousin Jill, thought of her mother, divorced and in asylum, and did not know which hurt most.
She liked the ice cream, but as you can imagine did not fully enjoy it. Now and then she cried.
That is where they were when the Spivvinses had invited Susan to the same place. And that is where Rose Ellen Pole and Susan Pevensie first met and made friends.
After Alberta did the introductions (not meaning Rose got the fact that Susan's last name was Pevensie, as shall be explained), Susan sat down at their table next to Rose and turned to her. The Spivvinses understood and paid her tea and sandwich. Themselves getting some at another table. And Su and Rose sat and talked at one end, while Alberta and Paul - soon joined by Harold - talked at the other end.
The first question Rose asked was:
"How was Jill as an archery pupil."
"The kind of archer that if there had been a shooting of arrows, she would have survived better than a train crash - even if her opponents were good warriors."
And this for the first time brightened up the face of Rose since she had heard the bad news same morning.
Wednesday, October 1, 2014
Nathan Coon and Spivvins
Nathan had prepared his little speech pretty carefully. And especially all the gestures. The tone. He had not reckoned on Lucy practically converting everyone of hers among the now deceased, just in the nick of time, nor on it showing thanks to rosaries and scapulars. He had not reckoned on the smile of her face giving Susan the comfort she really needed. He had not reckoned in Susan feeling guilt for having betrayed Lucy to him.
If psychologists get away with treating people, it is partly because anyone complaining seriously can usually be shut up and rendered thereby less credible and often enough even more uncomfortable than under his therapy.
It is also because their patients see them as the strong person. So that when reliance in such a one fails, it is at least not replaced by a stronger confidence in the patient himself or in what he stands for.
This they regularly reckon on. When they are wrong about a peaceful and modest person, they often refuse to see the evidence. Their superiority over their patient as to mental strength is so much a religion to them that if there is evidence for the contrary, they block it out. This was actually Nathan Coon's religion even more than his involvement in the Lodge of Tash. To him, they were simply his therapists, odd as that may seem to someone retaining his sanity more than therapists do.
And if the person they were treating as a patient is not peaceful and modest, if there is a quarrel, if they see evidence of something having gone wrong, they have a real swiftness in reinterpreting that new evidence as evidence of the patient "compensating" (for a real and really felt inferiority) in unrealistic and untenable ways. And as long as many people living ordinary lives and many people occasionally bossing over such support them, the therapists are often lucky enough to become right in such a supposition, even if they were not to start with, when the conflict broke out.
Nathan Coon arrived at Sevenoaks. He soon was at the scene of the trainwreck. He bit his lips when seeing some bodies were smashed. With some relief he spotted Susan as she was talking with the Spivvinses.
He made a sign to her as she sighted him. "Oh bother!" she sighed. She imagined he was going to offer some comfort she very clearly did not need from him.
She had this agreement with him. Probably nearly everyone going to a therapist had it back then. Except those often locked up or closely wateched over by others. You see, according to the deal she had no need to acknowledge she was going to therapy to people not aware of that. Back then such an admission would have felt much more shameful than now. These days films are nearly supposed to include a therapist, but back then that was not done in comedy or adventure, more like, if at all, in heavy films and even there hardly for the hero. So, to hide her not quite genial situation she had no need to tell strangers about him.
She had once or twice suspected him of not keeping his - unspoken - part of the bargain but of instead telling strangers about her behind her back. One or two new acquaintances suddenly just had dropped her - suspiciously enough in conditions that she might have been making a good impression on them by the first meeting, but they may have dropped out because of learning precisely such a thing. However, she was submitting herself to therapy and this had not stopped her from drowing these thoughts in a gush of confidence for him. Now, beside her sister's body, there was no such gush. Just an "oh bother" - even without such suspicions.
Then there was a short feeling of triumph as she recalled she had a choice. She could either go to him and pretend he was some other kind of acquaintance - or turn away the head and thus signal him it was absolutely not the right moment. She choose the latter alternative and turned her head back to the Spivvinses, the young Spivvins and the taxi driver from yesternight.
"So you were saying?" she said (and she had genuinely lost track of it while seeing Nathan Coon) with a most radiant smile. Like the one she had used when speaking to her best friend "George" to get rid of a bothersome but fortunately shy admirer.
Unfortunately for her, Nathan Coon was not a shy admirer. He bumped in from behind, touched her shoulder ever so gently, told her calmly and gently: "Susan, we would need to talk one of these days - it's quite alright if it isn't now, but ideally before the funeral ..."
Tom Spivvins, fortunately for her, seemed to grasp her discomfort with this person, especially when she also ever so gently got her shoulder away from under his hand (with a shudder and feeling of relief as he was forced to let her go in order not to make a scene). He stepped forth to more or less protect her integrity, a bit like his uncle had done to protect her against the cruel war hero last night.
"Sir, I do not know who you are in general or who you are to her, but she seems to mind your company."
Nathan had a routine for situations like this one. Susan knew it partly from when Peter had tried to protect Lucy - and when he had failed, mainly due to her. But this time he varied it.
"I am her uncle."
As this did not duly impress young Spivvins, as his uncle stepped forth and added "you don't look like it ..." he quickly got himself out of that question by adding:
"Her uncle by marriage. She is the niece of my late wife. We had been looking after her since the day when ... well, frankly, she had a nervous breakdown."
Susan was angry but too flabberghasted by the dishonesty. Was he going to tell the story of Lucy, which was dishonest even about her? She tried to open her mouth, couldn't when he just continued:
"We had to consult a psychiatrist. No, no, it's not that bad she is not going to therapy," he said with a dishonesty blatant to her. "She was locked up for a week." (Hey, yes, that was what happened to Lu! What an infamous ...) "and afterwards we were told not to worry. She was only a bit mentally frail, but she needed our attention. By now, it is two weeks we haven't heard from her, we are getting worried."
He didn't tell "we" happened to sound better than "I" in such contexts, besides being ironically true when compared to the lodge being involved. But he had been clumsy on a detail.
"We? I thought you were a widower!"
"Me and my new wife. Look here, you are really strangers to her, and to us, this is really none of your business. But fact remains, I remarried."
"In that case, she might not be getting along properly with her step aunt. Leace her alone."
The two Spivvinses, to the amazement of Susan, stepped closer to Nathan and made him take a step back. And the rest of their family were also stepping in behind them.
Nathan thus stepped back, but trying to wrench a victory from defeat, he turned to Susan and said: "Tomorrow by 1 p.m.? Will that be fine?"
"No." Susan couldn't believe she was getting out of his grasp so cheaply, and she enjoyed every moment of it.
"I didn't hear that. I'll be waiting at the office tomorrow ..."
"No."
The two Spivvinses were getting irritable:
"You heard she said no," said the uncle.
"A no is a no," said the Tom. Both were uncovering the arms and showing the fists by now.
And Nathan knew he had lost with them at hand. When he went off, she wondered what his next move would be, especially as he had told her while briskly walking away "... I see you have met some irresponsible people."
She knew that that might mean he was going to speak to some responsible people ... about her. And yet, she was too relieved to be afraid.
"If there had been a God" (she said in her mind) "it is almost as if He had heard the prayers of Lucy."
She told the Spivvinses cordially: "thank you" and ...
... she added to herself in her mind: "that means she would have had to forgive me for this to happen." And she recalled where Edmund had had that particular smile : on the Splendor Hyaline when leaving Tashbaan.
Wednesday, January 1, 2014
A Visit from The Kilns
But before they got to read the notebook, they had a visit. That is, first they went to Mass, then they went home, then drinking tea they sat down to open the notebook of Lucy. And then the doorbell rang. Audoin opened and yelled "Su, it's from the Kilns" so she went up and greeted her visitor. Audoin went in and left them a few moments.
Paxford came along with cider - five bottles of it, homemade from the Kilns.
"Jack and Warren are sorry they cannot come, they are helping an American lady, who is involved in a divorce affair."
"Oh, how awful for her. Is she keeping her children at least?"
"They are over here in England. They are bright and curious. David is ten and Douglas is eight going on nine in a couple of months."
"Well, if a parent keeps her children, she's the lucky parent, I reckon."
"So do I. And it seems she deserves it."
"Getting along with Jack?"
"Getting along may be a soft word. But as you know very well, Jack has a winning way."
"So have you."
Frank Paxford afforded her an apologetic smile. "But Mr Errol more so, I should think."
Of course Audoin came out again to tell Paxford there was more toast in the fireplace and another place for tea. Which Paxford stayed for before getting back.
The Planting of a Tree
"There are in fact countries where gardeners do try planting trees."
"Yes ....?"
"But it gets into an awful disorder when it does not all happen naturally. I mean, in France they have for years been planting trees in bakeries, and every Christmas the pastry bakers are obliged to cut them down and sell them as Yule logs."
"You mean, the French buy their Yule logs where they buy their pastry?"
"Yes, they call it 'bûche de Noël' and it is a very popular commerce around that Holy Season."
Susan looked hard at him to catch even a glimpse of irony in the eye but failed. Even so she suspected he was joking and that the bûche de Noël was some kind of cake. And even so she ate up the apple.
"Now, don't throw the core away, please."
"You want to plant it?"
"I might try to plant a tree just this once, even if that is not what gardeners usually do. Johnny Appleseed went all over the Mid West and helped grow orchards for making hard cider ... let us try."
And Fred Paxford dug a hole in the ground and Susan put the applecore into it. And the gardener shovelled earth over it. While explaining that this was for settlers also the easiest way to uphold a claim to being a settler. Such was the policy of the United States at the time.
"So the main activity of a gardener in England, when not imitating Johnny Appleseed or avoiding to imitate the anarchic gardeners of France, is simply keeping the garden clean?"
"Ah, indeed. When a tree falls down, from old age or from storm, you don't want to have the wood rotting where it fell, you chop it up for firewood, usually."
"Usually?"
"Well, my father once saw an apple tree fallen to the ground with very good wood, he did not make firewood of it."
"Oh?"
"He told his employer, one Digory Kirke, that one could make some furniture of it."
All the earth needed was on the apple seed in the Kilns' orchard, so he had resumed standing leaning on the spade.
"And Mister Kirke agreed, and they made a big wardrobe out of it."
"Oh?" Susan recalled one big wardrobe which just possibly could have been made out of apple wood.
"A huge wardrobe, they hung fur coats in it, you know they are longer than some other coats. Two doors and mirrors on the doors."
"Would that have been in a spare room in his house?"
"Oh, you have seen it? Yes, they kept it in a spare room. Houses were bigger before and during the war, now the Labour Government has reduced the possibility of living on the land like a gentleman."
A View on Apple Trees
One of the pleasures available in an hospital, whether you are kept in there by your sore body or someone else's assessment of your sore mind (or someone else's sore assessment of your mind, for that matter) is that of looking out of windows.
Trees and birds and clouds and the sky are so unrelated to the hospital, they are like balm for your eyes. One tree outside was precisly an apple tree.
Susan looked again at the book of palaeontology the doctor had left her to convince her of his philosophy of death, of evolution. And he did it the precisely wrong way.
He tried to give evidence, when the evidence was not very obviously on his side.
At least not for Susan who had heard Paxford's claim that the orchard in the Kilns had grown over two thousand years from a single apple seed, dropped accidentally by a bird. The "hundred feet of stems become roots as covered with soil from the apple tree leaves" of which, with all the floods, only ten feet were left, were all too close to the supposed evidence for evolution.
She broke out in a laugh and thought that that must have been Paxford's intention with the hoax.
"God bless that gardener!" she said out loud, and laughed because he didn't laugh when telling his splendid joke.
In looked a guard who asked "are you all right?" in a most worried voice.
One of the extreme displeasures of a hospital, when you are kept there because someone else made a sore assessment of your mind is not being allowed to enjoy a good mood, since it can be taken for a "maniac phase". She did shut up very quickly.
When she was alone again, she was despondent. Any place she had been staying before, laughing at a private joke would not have hurt her. Here it could get her very unwanted attentions.
She thought of another garden, as the "daughter of Eve" she had been called in Narnia. And of how the priests and her late sister Lucy called the Blessed Virgin Mary "the New Eve". And she thought of the Hail Mary she had nearly said when escaping from a would be ravisher. So, she prayed one Hail Mary - as she had learned it on her voayage to Italy, to Narni - and then looked out of the window again.
Humanly speaking she had no hope. If she had been raving out of her mind, she might have had the hope - not enjoyed it, but had it for real, to get out once she was put straight. But if she was already straight, when was she then supposed to get out if she was even so kept in? And yet she did not feel quite hopeless.
Even the Palaeontology book left on her nightstand was not as depressing as it had been when it came with greetings from Dr. Peter Sorner. Actually she felt there was a parallel with the orchard developing ... and still only ten feet left of the hundred feet theoretically involved in the process. In Palaeontology too very few if any places seemed to have thickness of ages stamped into the fossils. Unlike Geology where it is supposed to be automatically there because of slow deposit. She decided to get out into the parlour. In fossils of one place you often found fossils of one or two closely related slices of geological age.
Monday, December 30, 2013
Two Words with the Gardener
Susan went out to Paxford.
She took an apple from the tree, as the gardener invited her.
”A nice orchard. Wonder how old it is?”
”Oh, about two thousand years I guess," in his slow accent which some described as a drawl, "unless it is three thousand …”
Su look at him and he continued:
”Actually it started out as a single apple tree. It eez of course buried very far down, you cannot dig that deep."
Su looked even harder at him … not in a harsh, but in a very curious way.
”The soil we see, it is mostly from apple tree leaves and when it had started to cover the original tree, its branches started to become stems and take roots.
”So when their stems started to become covered with soil from apple tree leaves, their branches too started to become stems, and to take roots. And over the millennia the things that appear to be stems are by now ten, though they all started out as branches and the real stem is buried one hundred feet under ground, covered with soil that was once apple tree leaves."
Su did not quite belive him:
”But you planted some, didn’t you?”
”I never planted a tree in my whole life or my whole carreer as a gardener! How would things look if gardeners took care of the planting of trees?
”I mean, in that case we could plant trees anywhere we liked, even on house roofs, and nobody could be sure where the next apple tree would sprout. No, no, no … You got that totally wrong. All the trees in the orchard sprung from one single apple tree that sprang from an apple seed planted here by a bird three thousand years ago."
”Even the plum tree?”
”Sure enough, even the plum tree, you see, apple trees will evolve into plum trees under the right conditions. Under the wrong ones they will evolve into quince, real hard ones that you cannot eat but have to make marmalade of …"
She closed her eyes and opened them to make sures he was not dreaming. “You’re pulling my leg, right?”
”No, I am not, I have my hands on the spade, see … and I would not touch a lady's leg I wasn't married to, for that matter.”
She was somehow sure there was a joke behind the serious and even doleful façade.
"Wait a minute, Mr. Paxford, with 100 feet of soil, wouldn't it be unstable?"
If she had awaited one of his usual dire predictions, which somehow never came true - as far as the Lewis brothers had told him - she was not disappointed.
"Of course it is very unstable! Every once in a while it gets flooded and soil is lost to the sea or to land along the Tideway."
"But then it would not be any 100 feet of soil left by now, would there?"
"Of course not. The 100 feet down is what it would have been like without all the flooding. Many a tree trunk that was below us rotted into soil but was then flooded away."
"So basically the upside down pyramid of tree trunks becoming sideroots to branches becoming new tree trunks are purely theoretical?"
"There you have it. Wonder if there is even ten feet of soil below us with all the floods that happened."
"Do you think we risk one soon? I mean the Thames was flooded back two years ago ...?"
"Seeing what all is coming to, I should'nt wonder if there came a flood soon. Except, on days when I see a rain bow in the sky, I think the next disaster won't be a flood, it will be a fire ..."
She took an apple from the tree, as the gardener invited her.
”A nice orchard. Wonder how old it is?”
”Oh, about two thousand years I guess," in his slow accent which some described as a drawl, "unless it is three thousand …”
Su look at him and he continued:
”Actually it started out as a single apple tree. It eez of course buried very far down, you cannot dig that deep."
Su looked even harder at him … not in a harsh, but in a very curious way.
”The soil we see, it is mostly from apple tree leaves and when it had started to cover the original tree, its branches started to become stems and take roots.
”So when their stems started to become covered with soil from apple tree leaves, their branches too started to become stems, and to take roots. And over the millennia the things that appear to be stems are by now ten, though they all started out as branches and the real stem is buried one hundred feet under ground, covered with soil that was once apple tree leaves."
Su did not quite belive him:
”But you planted some, didn’t you?”
”I never planted a tree in my whole life or my whole carreer as a gardener! How would things look if gardeners took care of the planting of trees?
”I mean, in that case we could plant trees anywhere we liked, even on house roofs, and nobody could be sure where the next apple tree would sprout. No, no, no … You got that totally wrong. All the trees in the orchard sprung from one single apple tree that sprang from an apple seed planted here by a bird three thousand years ago."
”Even the plum tree?”
”Sure enough, even the plum tree, you see, apple trees will evolve into plum trees under the right conditions. Under the wrong ones they will evolve into quince, real hard ones that you cannot eat but have to make marmalade of …"
She closed her eyes and opened them to make sures he was not dreaming. “You’re pulling my leg, right?”
”No, I am not, I have my hands on the spade, see … and I would not touch a lady's leg I wasn't married to, for that matter.”
She was somehow sure there was a joke behind the serious and even doleful façade.
"Wait a minute, Mr. Paxford, with 100 feet of soil, wouldn't it be unstable?"
If she had awaited one of his usual dire predictions, which somehow never came true - as far as the Lewis brothers had told him - she was not disappointed.
"Of course it is very unstable! Every once in a while it gets flooded and soil is lost to the sea or to land along the Tideway."
"But then it would not be any 100 feet of soil left by now, would there?"
"Of course not. The 100 feet down is what it would have been like without all the flooding. Many a tree trunk that was below us rotted into soil but was then flooded away."
"So basically the upside down pyramid of tree trunks becoming sideroots to branches becoming new tree trunks are purely theoretical?"
"There you have it. Wonder if there is even ten feet of soil below us with all the floods that happened."
"Do you think we risk one soon? I mean the Thames was flooded back two years ago ...?"
"Seeing what all is coming to, I should'nt wonder if there came a flood soon. Except, on days when I see a rain bow in the sky, I think the next disaster won't be a flood, it will be a fire ..."
Monday, September 2, 2013
Tea yes, Tilak no
Father Brown was asked by the two Whites what he would be saying to a Hindoo Brahmin. As he had been in India, he answered he had accepted a cup of tea after refusing a tilak. As they were curious, Father Brown told this story of his conversation in the Brahmin's house with his host:
I was lost one evening in a town of India. There were people there in cassock, I thought they were Catholic priests. There was a Brahmin talking with them. I went there and talked to them too. Not long after starting I found out they were really of the so called Liberal Catholic Church. A syncretistic sect, say Spiritists with a Catholic style ritual. I disagreed with them. The Brahmin invited me to his home and I thought I might as well accept. When we arrived home, his wife wanted to give me a kind of mark on the forehead. A tilak they call it. I refused. I was still let in, with friendliest welcome, I enjoyed a wonderful meal with them, and then we drank tea. And the Brahmin asked me:
"Do you believe that all traditions are one?"
"In what manner?" I said.
"Every tradition will tell you, you must not kill."
"Mine tells me I must not kill a man. With a cow it is different."
The Brahmin refrained from contradicting me and went on:
"Every tradition will tell you, you must not steal. If you steal your next life is bad."
"Mine tells me a thief won Paradise when he was executed next to God. His next and eternal life is good."
"God executed as a thief? Do you seriously believe that?"
"Yes" I replied solemnly.
The Brahmin sat silently for quite a while. After some time I could bear it no longer and sipped some tea. When I put down the cup he continued:
"At least every tradition will tell you - excepting the worthless Muslim one - that gods have walked as men among us."
"I agree with half of your tradition by saying the true God walked as a man among us. I agree with half of the Muslim one by saying he was not one god among many others, there is one God. I disagree with both in saying He was made Man only once. And remains so eternally. And that God is One God in Three Persons."
"As in Creator, Upkeeper and Destroyer of every Universe, you mean?"
"No, God would have been Three Persons even if He had never created. But being Three Persons He was Eternal Love and of Love chose to Create. Of Love also he choose to Redeem, that is why He became Man and died on a Cross."
"And what do you think of our tradition?"
"In several aspects it is tainted with error by the Devil."
"Him you call the Destroyer?"
"Yes, we call Him the Destroyer and believe the Apollo of the Greeks and your Shiva is a mask of him and one under which he is not very much disguised."
"Is that why you refused the tilak earlier when we met?"
"That is why I will always refuse the tilak."
"If this is so, why are there traditions that are not Christian? Why are there Jews and Pagans, why are there Muslims? Do you call Protestants Christians?"
"Which ones of them? Salvation Army or Dean Inge? Pusey or Sankey and Moody?" - I decided to answer the Protestant question first.
"No doubt you have a reason for making these distinctions, like some of them being more or less Christian."
"Indeed: the Salvation Army takes most the main facts about our Salvation seriously. Dean Inge calls most of them a fable. Pusey took much of what the Church teaches as valid about how we get saved. Sankey and Moody have their own idea about it."
"And you consider Salvation Army more Christian than Dean Inge and Pusey more Christian than Sankey and Moody?"
"When God became Man, He made a Church with authority to teach all nations, not excepting the English one for other Churches."
"And the Jews?"
"They are the splinter of a people prepared to receive Christ, but refusing to do so themselves."
"And Muslims?"
"Are to Jews and Christians as Protestants or Mormons to us or Jainis and Buddhists to you."
"And Pagans?"
"They had refused the old teaching that the Hebrews kept."
"Hebrews and Jews is the same?"
"Jews are a tribe of the Hebrews, the one most directly concerned with rejecting Christ."
"Who were the first disciples?"
"Jews and more so Galileans. And Galileans were a kind of Jews."
"And if I were to say it is Pagans who kept and Hebrews who rejected the Old Tradition?"
"I would answer Pagans disagree among themselves. Hindoos and Indians of America do not agree, nor do Shintoists and Confucians. Nor are they at one with Parsees or with those Pagans who became Christians."
"But if I were to say the disagreements are to get the vulgar off the track, there is agreement among the traditions of the wise!"
"Galileans were vulgar Jews. God was crucified among vulgar thieves. And there is one more thing."
"Which is?"
"By appealing to secret tradition, you make yourself unable to verify where the traditions agree and not. Two traditions may disagree nearly completely except about their secrecy. Two people from those traditions may say to each other a thing about keeping their traditions secret, and both may conclude very wrongly that they agree about religion, when all they agree about is despising most of those Christ died for."
"Is not loftiness and detachment more important than doctrine?"
"No. That is a hideous spiritual pride, an arrogance of the worst sort."
"Is it not possible to be detached from taking pride in one's knowledge by saying knowledge is not important?"
"Saying knowledge is not important sounds too much like a hideous saying I have heard here in India: victory and defeat are the same. That is a very great blasphemy, if you speak about ultimate such, not just earthly. It detaches one from God who alone can give ultimate victory and attaches one to darkness and ultimate defeat."
"Then why did Krishna say so?"
"Because he was no god but a mistaken man."
"Why do our poets tell us he inspired Arjuna to victory? Why do they tell us he ascended to Heaven after dying?"
"Your poets say the soul was received by the gods high above us, no one to see it with his eyes."
"Do you not believe things no man has seen with his eyes?"
"We do, but on authority of Him whom several eyes saw resurrected after the Crucifixion. It was He who unfolded all the Secrets, not a merely human poet."
"And Ascension? Was not that like Krishna's soul ascending to Heaven?"
"No, the Ascension we believe in was before the eyes of the first Disciples so chosen to witness it."
"It was as a living body He ascended then?"
"As a living body He ascended, as a living body we eat His flesh and drink His blood."
"Let me go, this is too strong for me."
"No, I will not let you go, and it is good for you."
The Brahmin was baptised little later. With his wife and children. And grandchildren.
When Father Brown said these last words, the Whites said: "so will we be!" And Simon thought his son looked happier and saner than ever since he was sent to that horrible school.
Father Brown concluded the story: No longer tending the temple was of course ruin to him in the town, so it was fortunate that Goa, under the Portuguese, was near by. He found work as a translator and teacher of Vedic literature - for students whose purpose was purely literary and linguistic. And perhaps historic too. He once was approached by a Hindoo and refused to even talk to him. Now he is dead, his widow lived in the monastery some time afterwards.
Saturday, June 22, 2013
Spivvins Needs a Lesson - they said
A few old men were meeting in an hotel lounge to drink good beer and expensive whisky - Chivas Regal - and to discuss. Unlike the Inklings what they were discussing was not chapters in books they were writing or principles behind medieval manners or stories.
A set of men used to meeting in their networks for shady and smudgy purposes were about to discuss what they called a "case." They were big believers in being jerks. If they gave each other a hard time, they were helping each other to grow. If they were doing so to someone else, they were making someone else grow. Hard times was the very thing that helped you grow. Good times were scarce. Desirable of course, and to be enjoyed, if opportunity was given (with due fear of the others who might help you grow if you enjoyed them too much), but scarce.
Wait a minute ... were they really that scarce? Why in that case were they making the good times more scarce for others? Would seem a bit pointless if good times were really all that scarce in themselves. Maybe they were jealous because with all this belief in "growing" and "maturing" they were themselves not having the best of times. But the best of their times were when planning to "help" someone else "grow" or "mature".
I've known sets that really specialised in "helping" men "grow" who were not part of their network and were not deserving its evil attentions - since either they had just been doing well generally or doing some ill only to that network to stop it from doing ill. They can take a beggar and claim him for their adept. And since society is so used to them doing such to their adepts and so little used to standing up to such networks, the people who would normally have helped out concluded placently it was just another one of their new adepts, one who needed and wanted their help to grow. There are people who, when a beggar receives a gift from one in someone else's network will accept that network's claim to own the beggar.
"Spivvins cooked my meat too meaty today! Almost as if he were claiming to be a real cook!"
"Right. And yesterday my wine was far too winy."
"Last year, he was painting my house green. It was far too green after he had painted it."
"My niece showed me some of his water colour paintings. Far too watery, if you see what I mean. Fades as they say in French."
There one man coughed, turned red as if choking, and said: "don't say that. Please don't say that!"
They knew very well what he meant, but they liked to turn the knife around in the wound. They considered it helped the wounded man grow.
"What do you mean?"
"Is it too stuffy? Someone let out gas ...?"
He put up a brave face and said: "that was the reason we were giving Adolf his Sonderbehandlung; and look how he got back at us!"
They sighed.
And it was Nathan Coon, and none else, who finally said: "Well, I guess we'll have to give Spivvins his Sonderbehandlung now ... Adolf or no Adolf ..."
Who were they to argue with a psychiatrist? Even supposing they had had sufficient piety to argue energetically and efficaciously against "giving lessons" to people who were not in their network and might have been better off without them.
A few weeks later, Spivvins' restaurant had gone bankrupt.
A set of men used to meeting in their networks for shady and smudgy purposes were about to discuss what they called a "case." They were big believers in being jerks. If they gave each other a hard time, they were helping each other to grow. If they were doing so to someone else, they were making someone else grow. Hard times was the very thing that helped you grow. Good times were scarce. Desirable of course, and to be enjoyed, if opportunity was given (with due fear of the others who might help you grow if you enjoyed them too much), but scarce.
Wait a minute ... were they really that scarce? Why in that case were they making the good times more scarce for others? Would seem a bit pointless if good times were really all that scarce in themselves. Maybe they were jealous because with all this belief in "growing" and "maturing" they were themselves not having the best of times. But the best of their times were when planning to "help" someone else "grow" or "mature".
I've known sets that really specialised in "helping" men "grow" who were not part of their network and were not deserving its evil attentions - since either they had just been doing well generally or doing some ill only to that network to stop it from doing ill. They can take a beggar and claim him for their adept. And since society is so used to them doing such to their adepts and so little used to standing up to such networks, the people who would normally have helped out concluded placently it was just another one of their new adepts, one who needed and wanted their help to grow. There are people who, when a beggar receives a gift from one in someone else's network will accept that network's claim to own the beggar.
"Spivvins cooked my meat too meaty today! Almost as if he were claiming to be a real cook!"
"Right. And yesterday my wine was far too winy."
"Last year, he was painting my house green. It was far too green after he had painted it."
"My niece showed me some of his water colour paintings. Far too watery, if you see what I mean. Fades as they say in French."
There one man coughed, turned red as if choking, and said: "don't say that. Please don't say that!"
They knew very well what he meant, but they liked to turn the knife around in the wound. They considered it helped the wounded man grow.
"What do you mean?"
"Is it too stuffy? Someone let out gas ...?"
He put up a brave face and said: "that was the reason we were giving Adolf his Sonderbehandlung; and look how he got back at us!"
They sighed.
And it was Nathan Coon, and none else, who finally said: "Well, I guess we'll have to give Spivvins his Sonderbehandlung now ... Adolf or no Adolf ..."
Who were they to argue with a psychiatrist? Even supposing they had had sufficient piety to argue energetically and efficaciously against "giving lessons" to people who were not in their network and might have been better off without them.
A few weeks later, Spivvins' restaurant had gone bankrupt.
Tuesday, May 14, 2013
Barrister Popplewell's pleading for Susan Pevensie
Your Honour!
Nobody is denying, least of all my client, that she colluded with the Spivvins family to illegally defend these from policemen legally charged with taking their children away from them. Was it evil? Was it hasty, to the point of mental insanity?
My client may indeed be described as hasty, if you like. But haste is sometimes required. When the lives and freedoms of innocent people are at stake, one cannot without gross dishonour stand by and wait till one has a chance to make everything the legal way.
In a recent war, the Germans learned at a great price that saving lives from a bloody dictator sometimes required illegal action. When it comes to saving British pilots, people who did that faced charges of high treason if caught. RAF honours them. When it comes to saving Jews from terrible suffering and humiliation, possibly death, some who did that and are honoured in Yad Vashem did so by laying aside for a moment the respect for the legal forms of their countries.
I know that the family my client was helping by shooting arrows into some policemen are at a safe place, I have talked to them, it seems very clear that they could at the hands of the Social Assistant in question expect no freedom such as families are used to.
Why? Because the mother was illiterate and the father a headstrong Catholic. Much as we dislike illiteracy, it cannot be an adequate ground for taking children away from a mother. Much as we dislike Jesuit fanaticism - though giving Father Brown of that order his due, they are not all like what we have heard - being a Catholic, however headstrong cannot be a ground for the taking away of children from both parents. Even under the Penal laws, childrehn could only be taken away from a Catholic parent at the behest of an Anglican or Puritan one.
And, one more reason for this lack of secured rights, because the social worker in question - responsible and quiet as she may seem when heard in court - had been among his worst school time harassers. Margaret Cholmondeley, called Cholmondeley Major because of her built, was not acting like a benevolent distributor of gifts in her school days, but she terrorised, with a few others, her comrades. They liked to bully almost everyone weaker than themselves in a school that was closed down some ten years ago, called Experiment House. After leaving that school, she managed to behave herself and gain some confidence. Peter Spivvins - who is also accused along with Susan Pevensie and with his wife and who has managed to keep away - was not among the weakest in the school, but his fiancée, now wife, had been illegally taken away from a residential school for Esquimaux in Canada, and he had no reason to suppose this secret would not be abused if given away to his harrassers or, especially, their parents.
Obviously, in a civilised country, this cannot happen. And as obviously we like to think of England as a civilised country. But sometimes barbarism and dictatorship can nevertheless creep in. An institution that is supposed to be benevolent can become poisoned with a spirit of dictatorship, can become a miniature copy of the recent Nazi and the present Communist dictatorships on the Continent. I wonder whether certain parts of Canada cannot be counted among the dictatorships too. At least when dealing with Esquimaux, with Indians and with French Canadians.
If Sarah Spivvins - also among the accused today, and also keeping away - had been denounced when her now husband was attending Experiment House at the request of an Uncle - she might not ever have had the children for whose welfare Miss Cholmondeley is so concerned. But, what with our relations to Canada, if the children had been taken away, they might have been brought where they also would in their turn risk sterilisation. My clients' coaccused wanted to avoid this at all costs. My client helped them.
My case can be summed up so that my client, was in this case, as earlier when saving a child from forced abortion (I have talked to that family too, the teen mother is now married to a gipsy), acted precisely as the heroes of the recent war did. She should not only be acquitted, but honoured as a hero.
I rest my case.
Applause broke out in the court room. The judge banged the club onto the bar to ask for quiet. He got the jury to retire for deliberation. Five minutes later the jury and the judge were back, and Susan Pevensie was acquitted, along with the absent Peter and Sarah Spivvins, who would have otherwise risked being condemned in contumaciam.
Sunday, April 21, 2013
The Idol and the Spell
When Georgina opened her eyes, she was tied hands on back - a situation she knew from earlier years (as you will know if you have read those of Enid Blyton's books where the title starts with "Five ..."). George was - poor guy - swaying back and forth with closed eyes in front of a man who seemed to dominate him. A thin and short man. Behind them there was some kind of broad fire - like fire for barbecues, but with no grate on it and much broader than any barbecue she had seen yet. She realised why the room was hot and she was thirsty.
Behind that there was some idol. Six arms, like the statues of Shiva in India. But unlike those, the head was a vulture's head, and the fingers and toes were rather claws, just as there was a beak on the vulture's head. It was an evil idol. I mean, idols are not exactly good, at least as far as Christianity is concerned, but Roman and Greek ones were usually at least gentle. This one was avid for blood.
"You thought you could rebel, that you could shake off Tash."
"Yes," said George in a very dry and lifeless voice.
What she heard thereafter, she was not able to recall without vomiting, so she has not told word for word. But it included a very abject submission from the poor enchanted George and also a very ugly incantation to someone or something called Tash (more than once called inexorable) by the evil little man. She looked about for something that could comfort her. At her side there was a Roman Catholic priest. But he too seemed under some daze.
Beyond him there was Simon, the father of George.
She got no further in looking about, since what happened before the idol called her attention back to it.
"Show us you are a vulture ..."
George started crying out with shrieks more birdish than human. And not the nicest birds at that. Then he started pecking on the ground, incredibly fast for a human as if guided by the forces of a bird, he picked up an unfortunate frog and swallowed it alive.
"Show us you can kill ..." the small man handed George a knife. A crooked knife like those found in the far off eastern countries. "Kill that girl" he said and pointed at Georgina.
George took the knife and started against his fiancée, the stopped.
"You need to practise a bit first. Pick some more food from the ground."
And George started pecking again, not using his hands except to still hold that crooked knife. He pecked after a very fortunate rat, whe ran away just in time. And he came closer and closer to Georgina.
She was sure he was so much under a spell that he would eventually kill her unless something happened. What could break a spell like that? Well, maybe some Christian confession of the truth. Of Christ's triumph over hell.
"The plowman answered then the priest,
Sir, I believe in Jesus Christ
Who suffered death and harrowed Hell
As I have heard mine elders tell."
As she said those words a few things happened. The evil man went forth to slap her. George, who was still under the spell and acted like a bird somehow found the independence to be a bird who shoved that man (who was occupied with other things than controlling him), and he shoved him so he fell into the fire. And the priest opened his eyes, just in time to hear the agony of the evil man, and see him try to get out of the fire but being pushed back time after time by George, who was using the pecking technique - as vulturish as the spell had made him.
Behind that there was some idol. Six arms, like the statues of Shiva in India. But unlike those, the head was a vulture's head, and the fingers and toes were rather claws, just as there was a beak on the vulture's head. It was an evil idol. I mean, idols are not exactly good, at least as far as Christianity is concerned, but Roman and Greek ones were usually at least gentle. This one was avid for blood.
"You thought you could rebel, that you could shake off Tash."
"Yes," said George in a very dry and lifeless voice.
What she heard thereafter, she was not able to recall without vomiting, so she has not told word for word. But it included a very abject submission from the poor enchanted George and also a very ugly incantation to someone or something called Tash (more than once called inexorable) by the evil little man. She looked about for something that could comfort her. At her side there was a Roman Catholic priest. But he too seemed under some daze.
Beyond him there was Simon, the father of George.
She got no further in looking about, since what happened before the idol called her attention back to it.
"Show us you are a vulture ..."
George started crying out with shrieks more birdish than human. And not the nicest birds at that. Then he started pecking on the ground, incredibly fast for a human as if guided by the forces of a bird, he picked up an unfortunate frog and swallowed it alive.
"Show us you can kill ..." the small man handed George a knife. A crooked knife like those found in the far off eastern countries. "Kill that girl" he said and pointed at Georgina.
George took the knife and started against his fiancée, the stopped.
"You need to practise a bit first. Pick some more food from the ground."
And George started pecking again, not using his hands except to still hold that crooked knife. He pecked after a very fortunate rat, whe ran away just in time. And he came closer and closer to Georgina.
She was sure he was so much under a spell that he would eventually kill her unless something happened. What could break a spell like that? Well, maybe some Christian confession of the truth. Of Christ's triumph over hell.
Sir, I believe in Jesus Christ
Who suffered death and harrowed Hell
As I have heard mine elders tell."
As she said those words a few things happened. The evil man went forth to slap her. George, who was still under the spell and acted like a bird somehow found the independence to be a bird who shoved that man (who was occupied with other things than controlling him), and he shoved him so he fell into the fire. And the priest opened his eyes, just in time to hear the agony of the evil man, and see him try to get out of the fire but being pushed back time after time by George, who was using the pecking technique - as vulturish as the spell had made him.
Saturday, April 20, 2013
An Interview with the Shrink
"So, do you know where your pupil, Miss Rose E. Pole, is now?"
Susan remained silent.
"Did you hear my question?"
Susan did not deign to answer.
"She might be in a very bad state," the doctor said to his assistant. "I'll try another one."
He turned back to Susan.
"It is important that we know where Rose is."
"Why? So you can force her to an abortion?"
"Oh, why are you so demonising? You know that is illegal."
Susan said nothing. God knows what she would have done if certain drugs used now had been in use back then.
"Why are you against abortion anyway? You know she cannot get a job, you know her child would depend on her parents?"
Susan could not believe she heard such cynicism. And from a doctor. Then she looked again at the assistant, the man who had envied the Dresden bomber. Now she did believe it.
"You mean that life is sacred to you, in some way?"
"Isn't it to you?" Susan had to force herself to dare respond like that, but she would not respond with less anymosity, and she did not dare not to respond. Like it was a snake and a mouse did not dare take its eyes off it.
"In a manner of speaking, yes."
He paused.
"In a manner of speaking, life is sacred. But it is short. It is my art which is long. And now it teaches us how to save lives noone could save before. Or to deal death."
"Without death," he continued, as she looked at him sullenly, "life would be crowded and choke itself to death."
She saw a flaw: "It could hardly do that if there was no death for life to choke itself to, even by getting crowded."
"Supposing it did not? Supposing every life engendered was born, and every life born stayed alive for all eternity - on this little earth of ours. But however much you dislike death, it won't happen like that. Death is to the biosphere what surgeons are to bodies."
He continued as she bit her lips: "A surgeon - usually - leaves what is healthy in the body. Death leaves only - that also just usually - what is the most healthy."
"That is a lie." She knew her siblings and cousin and former pupil had not been sick, and even the old ones, Professor Kirke and Miss Plummer, were - except for Professor Kirke's white hairs and ill hearing, from an episode with cannibals with loud drums, as healthy as people can expect when sixtyish.
"Statistically it is true. What does science, what does life as a whole, care about the individual exceptions?"
"I do care. I am neither 'science,' nor 'life as a whole,' but I do care. Have you met them by the way?"
"Met whom?"
"Science. And life-as-a-whole. Have you met them?"
The doctor nodded to his assistant. He was scribbling.
What he was scribbling she was given an idea of as the doctor said:
"My dear. We must take things easy. We will give you time to rest and think things out. You know - 'science' and 'life as a whole' are not people."
She was flabberghasted. She had never said they were. That had been her whole point ... was he an idiot? She opened her mouth ...
"Hush now. You needn't thank me for pointing out the obvious to you. That is what we are for, here in the loonybin."
She silently appreciated his wonderful "magnanimity".
"But to continue ... I will venture on a bit ... though usually I would just have left you now for at least a month ... You see, death is what drives evolution forward. Without death we would be amoebas."
"It would seem it's rather death that turns us over to amoebas ... or whatever makes corpses smell."
"Well - before it did that, it killed some amoebas in the mud that did not cooperate, while the others who did got to be a manycelled animal."
She was silent.
"Later on, death killed off some manycelled animals because they had no symmetry - and gave a chance to the first spine carrying animal, which conveniently had just developed."
"How convenient!"
"Are you aware how very much you look like your sister when you say that? She also would not believe evolution."
"Maybe she had some sense?"
"Not exactly what you thought yourself back then. Remember, it was you who confided her to us, both occasions."
She was silent, since she regretted that. But he who had taken advantage was hardly the person to blame her.
"Formerly, people would argue that God created the world. With all species. As far as the species are concerned evolution is God. Death is our god. Death who kills off what does not fit into its environment."
"Wouldn't that be a smelly kind of god? Death brings corruption, most often, and corruption smells."
The doctor turned sadly his eyes to the assitant.
"So there, so there ..." the doctor said soothingly: "don't you believe in science?"
"Which one of them?"
"Well, evolution, for one!"
"As mostly atheist agnostic over past few years, I have a hard time believing in anything supernatural." (She did not feel worth mentioning that she had been a Catholic for a month or so before falling away again after failing to confess the betrayal against Lucy)
"Supernatural?" the doctor raised his voice ... "but it is not supernatural. It's as natural as anything there is. It's as natural as death. It's ... some of us call it the life force. Nothing like a personal god or anything of course."
"Isn't that supernatural?"
The doctor fell silent. He walked to the window. He looked out.
"We'll have to talk about evolution another time. Not now."
Then he paused again. He walked back to Susan and took another subject:
"You must admit that without abortion there would be too many people on earth, right?"
"No, not exactly right."
"Think of it. Some girls get pregnant and cannot afford it. What becomes of their offspring? Beggars!"
He pronounced the word as if it were dirtier than words like "slut".
"Well, I would think any sane beggar prefers having been born," ventured Susan.
"No, no, no: any sane beggar knows he is a burden to society and regrets the day he was born and conceived. You will at least admit condoms are useful to decrease the numbers of the unproductive?"
"No, if they are unproductive it just means they are out of work, usually."
"But if there was no work for them to earn their living with ... why should they have the burden of existance?"
Susan felt as if she was talking to a doctor who had been active in experiments in those horrid camps. Pa said that too few doctors were tried at Nuremberg - and ma heartily agreed. While they lived, that is.
"Why could there not be work for them?"
"They are no longer needed at the farms for one. Nearly everyone lives in cities nowadays. More and more so, actually. So, if one cannot find a decent work in a city, one might as well not have been born."
"If left to themselves, with enough food, people usually find something to do and appreciate each other for, economically as well."
"But have you thought what happens when the petrol ceases to flow? Tractors won't work, so less food will be produced. Cars won't work, so less of the food will get to town. People will die in millions!"
"It's hardly tractors and cars that produce the food ..."
"What is that supposed to mean?"
"With people getting back to the country, there will be less need of tractors for plowing, or none at all, and for them no need of the cars either, since they live where the food grows."
"But people are not getting back to the country. It's against progress. It's against evolution. It's against the development."
"How do you know that?"
"Look at what's happening now. People are more and more moving away from farms, especially after the tractors took over their work during war. They won't want to go back. They'd rather die than go back."
"But why?"
"Because it has been going on for quite a while and the trend has not been reversed."
Susan thought a bit of whether there had not been an opposite trend away from cities during the fall of the Roman Empire, but history was not her best subject. So she asked a more principled question:
"So if a trend has gone on in one direction, without being reversed, does that mean to you it will go on forever in that direction?"
"Maybe not forever, but highly unlikelty it changes over night either."
"Why not try to change it to save lives, then?"
"Because that would be against progress."
"Even if progress kills?"
"Yes."
"Just because it is a trend that has been going on?"
"Yes."
"Now, that is fuddled!"
She was usually in the habit of thinking so herself up till now, but she was not so hard into the habit as to condone murderous conclusions of it.
"Ah, it is I who am fuddled, is it?"
"It was you who said ..."
"Enough. It was you who shot arrows into the arm of a policeman, in the vain hope to stop an abortion."
"Vain or not, that is why I did it." Susan did not feel any regrets about that.
"Now, that is what I call fuddled. And here the one who decides what is fuddled is ... I."
He said so with tragic grandour, turned and told his assistant: "she'll have to stay a few days at least," and then walked out.
Susan remained silent.
"Did you hear my question?"
Susan did not deign to answer.
"She might be in a very bad state," the doctor said to his assistant. "I'll try another one."
He turned back to Susan.
"It is important that we know where Rose is."
"Why? So you can force her to an abortion?"
"Oh, why are you so demonising? You know that is illegal."
Susan said nothing. God knows what she would have done if certain drugs used now had been in use back then.
"Why are you against abortion anyway? You know she cannot get a job, you know her child would depend on her parents?"
Susan could not believe she heard such cynicism. And from a doctor. Then she looked again at the assistant, the man who had envied the Dresden bomber. Now she did believe it.
"You mean that life is sacred to you, in some way?"
"Isn't it to you?" Susan had to force herself to dare respond like that, but she would not respond with less anymosity, and she did not dare not to respond. Like it was a snake and a mouse did not dare take its eyes off it.
"In a manner of speaking, yes."
He paused.
"In a manner of speaking, life is sacred. But it is short. It is my art which is long. And now it teaches us how to save lives noone could save before. Or to deal death."
"Without death," he continued, as she looked at him sullenly, "life would be crowded and choke itself to death."
She saw a flaw: "It could hardly do that if there was no death for life to choke itself to, even by getting crowded."
"Supposing it did not? Supposing every life engendered was born, and every life born stayed alive for all eternity - on this little earth of ours. But however much you dislike death, it won't happen like that. Death is to the biosphere what surgeons are to bodies."
He continued as she bit her lips: "A surgeon - usually - leaves what is healthy in the body. Death leaves only - that also just usually - what is the most healthy."
"That is a lie." She knew her siblings and cousin and former pupil had not been sick, and even the old ones, Professor Kirke and Miss Plummer, were - except for Professor Kirke's white hairs and ill hearing, from an episode with cannibals with loud drums, as healthy as people can expect when sixtyish.
"Statistically it is true. What does science, what does life as a whole, care about the individual exceptions?"
"I do care. I am neither 'science,' nor 'life as a whole,' but I do care. Have you met them by the way?"
"Met whom?"
"Science. And life-as-a-whole. Have you met them?"
The doctor nodded to his assistant. He was scribbling.
What he was scribbling she was given an idea of as the doctor said:
"My dear. We must take things easy. We will give you time to rest and think things out. You know - 'science' and 'life as a whole' are not people."
She was flabberghasted. She had never said they were. That had been her whole point ... was he an idiot? She opened her mouth ...
"Hush now. You needn't thank me for pointing out the obvious to you. That is what we are for, here in the loonybin."
She silently appreciated his wonderful "magnanimity".
"But to continue ... I will venture on a bit ... though usually I would just have left you now for at least a month ... You see, death is what drives evolution forward. Without death we would be amoebas."
"It would seem it's rather death that turns us over to amoebas ... or whatever makes corpses smell."
"Well - before it did that, it killed some amoebas in the mud that did not cooperate, while the others who did got to be a manycelled animal."
She was silent.
"Later on, death killed off some manycelled animals because they had no symmetry - and gave a chance to the first spine carrying animal, which conveniently had just developed."
"How convenient!"
"Are you aware how very much you look like your sister when you say that? She also would not believe evolution."
"Maybe she had some sense?"
"Not exactly what you thought yourself back then. Remember, it was you who confided her to us, both occasions."
She was silent, since she regretted that. But he who had taken advantage was hardly the person to blame her.
"Formerly, people would argue that God created the world. With all species. As far as the species are concerned evolution is God. Death is our god. Death who kills off what does not fit into its environment."
"Wouldn't that be a smelly kind of god? Death brings corruption, most often, and corruption smells."
The doctor turned sadly his eyes to the assitant.
"So there, so there ..." the doctor said soothingly: "don't you believe in science?"
"Which one of them?"
"Well, evolution, for one!"
"As mostly atheist agnostic over past few years, I have a hard time believing in anything supernatural." (She did not feel worth mentioning that she had been a Catholic for a month or so before falling away again after failing to confess the betrayal against Lucy)
"Supernatural?" the doctor raised his voice ... "but it is not supernatural. It's as natural as anything there is. It's as natural as death. It's ... some of us call it the life force. Nothing like a personal god or anything of course."
"Isn't that supernatural?"
The doctor fell silent. He walked to the window. He looked out.
"We'll have to talk about evolution another time. Not now."
Then he paused again. He walked back to Susan and took another subject:
"You must admit that without abortion there would be too many people on earth, right?"
"No, not exactly right."
"Think of it. Some girls get pregnant and cannot afford it. What becomes of their offspring? Beggars!"
He pronounced the word as if it were dirtier than words like "slut".
"Well, I would think any sane beggar prefers having been born," ventured Susan.
"No, no, no: any sane beggar knows he is a burden to society and regrets the day he was born and conceived. You will at least admit condoms are useful to decrease the numbers of the unproductive?"
"No, if they are unproductive it just means they are out of work, usually."
"But if there was no work for them to earn their living with ... why should they have the burden of existance?"
Susan felt as if she was talking to a doctor who had been active in experiments in those horrid camps. Pa said that too few doctors were tried at Nuremberg - and ma heartily agreed. While they lived, that is.
"Why could there not be work for them?"
"They are no longer needed at the farms for one. Nearly everyone lives in cities nowadays. More and more so, actually. So, if one cannot find a decent work in a city, one might as well not have been born."
"If left to themselves, with enough food, people usually find something to do and appreciate each other for, economically as well."
"But have you thought what happens when the petrol ceases to flow? Tractors won't work, so less food will be produced. Cars won't work, so less of the food will get to town. People will die in millions!"
"It's hardly tractors and cars that produce the food ..."
"What is that supposed to mean?"
"With people getting back to the country, there will be less need of tractors for plowing, or none at all, and for them no need of the cars either, since they live where the food grows."
"But people are not getting back to the country. It's against progress. It's against evolution. It's against the development."
"How do you know that?"
"Look at what's happening now. People are more and more moving away from farms, especially after the tractors took over their work during war. They won't want to go back. They'd rather die than go back."
"But why?"
"Because it has been going on for quite a while and the trend has not been reversed."
Susan thought a bit of whether there had not been an opposite trend away from cities during the fall of the Roman Empire, but history was not her best subject. So she asked a more principled question:
"So if a trend has gone on in one direction, without being reversed, does that mean to you it will go on forever in that direction?"
"Maybe not forever, but highly unlikelty it changes over night either."
"Why not try to change it to save lives, then?"
"Because that would be against progress."
"Even if progress kills?"
"Yes."
"Just because it is a trend that has been going on?"
"Yes."
"Now, that is fuddled!"
She was usually in the habit of thinking so herself up till now, but she was not so hard into the habit as to condone murderous conclusions of it.
"Ah, it is I who am fuddled, is it?"
"It was you who said ..."
"Enough. It was you who shot arrows into the arm of a policeman, in the vain hope to stop an abortion."
"Vain or not, that is why I did it." Susan did not feel any regrets about that.
"Now, that is what I call fuddled. And here the one who decides what is fuddled is ... I."
He said so with tragic grandour, turned and told his assistant: "she'll have to stay a few days at least," and then walked out.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)